Crafting the Ultimate Yuletide Eggnog: A Celebration in a Cup

By Larissa C December 18, 2023

Eggnog, often linked with heartwarming holiday gatherings and treasured family customs, is a delightful Christmas beverage rooted in British heritage. Contrary to popular belief, its origins are not in the heart of America but rather in British culture, reminiscent of Shakespeare’s character Falstaff’s favorite concoction known as “sack posset.” This historical drink was crafted from beaten egg yolks, milk, sugar, and fortified wine. While the recipes for eggnog may differ significantly, one crucial element remains constant – the inclusion of a robust and rich liqueur. Whether it’s sherry, Madeira, whiskey, rum, or brandy, this alcoholic infusion serves as the cornerstone of this beloved Christmas libation. What sets the finest eggnog apart from the rest is its refined and creamy texture, achieved by meticulously beating the eggs separately. And, of course, no eggnog would be complete without a generous dusting of freshly grated nutmeg.

image credit: Anna Puzatykh/ Shutterstock


4 Eggs, separated
75g Sugar (adjust to your taste)
350ml Whole milk
300ml Double cream
200ml Brandy
200ml Dark rum
Freshly grated Nutmeg (to your liking)


Step 1: Start by delicately separating the egg yolks from the whites. Whisk the egg yolks and half of the sugar in a mixing bowl until the mixture becomes thick and pale consistency. Add a small hint of nutmeg for that quintessential holiday essence. Next, introduce the whole milk, double cream, and your choice of spirits, such as brandy and dark rum, into the mix.

Step 2: Whipping Up the Egg Whites In a separate, impeccably clean bowl, whip the egg whites until they form gentle, soft peaks. Gradually incorporate the remaining sugar, ensuring the blend maintains its light and airy texture.

Step 3: Harmonizing the Components Now, it’s time to unite the two components. Carefully fold the whipped egg whites into the yolk mixture. This gentle amalgamation of the egg whites infuses your eggnog with a luxurious texture.

Step 4: Presenting and Garnishing Pour your handcrafted eggnog into cups or goblets, filling them with the smooth concoction. As a finishing touch, generously sprinkle freshly grated nutmeg over each serving. The fragrant nutmeg not only elevates the flavor but also imparts a festive touch to your eggnog.

image credit: Elena Shashkina/ Shutterstock

With this recipe, you can savor the epitome of homemade eggnog, a cherished Christmas classic that has graced holiday festivities for generations. Whether you relish it as a comforting tradition or a delightful indulgence, the creamy, opulent, and subtly spiced notes of this Christmas eggnog are certain to warm your heart and immerse you in the holiday ambiance. Here’s to a festive season brimming with merriment, warmth, and the perfect eggnog!